Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner Since 1898
C M Steele Insurance Brokers has served clients since 1898 with unwavering dedication to personalized service and industry expertise. Founded by Omer L. Steele, our firm initially specialized in fire and boiler insurance before expanding under Charles Steele's leadership after his service in the RCAF. Over decades, we've maintained a family-owned ethos while embracing technological advancements like our CSR24 client portal and 24/7 claims reporting. Our team of licensed professionals prioritizes trust through transparent communication and tailored insurance solutions. With competitive market access, we deliver value through customized plans for personal and commercial clients.Our 125-year legacy reflects commitment to evolving with client needs while preserving core principles of integrity and service excellence. We operate from two Ontario locations, serving Port Colborne, Stoney Creek, and surrounding Niagara Peninsula areas. Our staff combines generational experience with modern convenience features like instant online quotes and electronic document signing. This balance of tradition and innovation ensures we protect what matters most to our clients. Winston Churchill's philosophy of continuous improvement guides our approach to insurance brokerage services.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Life Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Boat Insurance
Tenant Insurance
Health Insurance
Small Business Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Condo Insurance
Highlights and features
- We offer 125 years of combined insurance expertise and market knowledge.
- Our CSR24 portal provides 24/7 policy management and instant quote capabilities.
- We maintain A+ rated insurance carrier partnerships for reliable coverage options.
- Our family-owned structure ensures personalized service and community commitment.
- We provide customized insurance solutions for unique personal and business needs.
What people say
Exceptional service
Knowledgeable staff
Efficient claims
Personalized attention
Generational expertise
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance solutions with instant online quoting capabilities. Our policies include accident benefits, liability protection, and coverage for various vehicle types including classic cars. Our licensed brokers help clients navigate coverage options and secure competitive rates through multiple insurance carriers.
Home Insurance
Our home insurance offerings cover primary residences, condos, and cottages with customizable policies. Services include risk assessment, policy customization, and claims assistance. We offer coverage for property damage, liability, and additional living expenses with options for unique property requirements.
Commercial Insurance
We specialize in tailored commercial insurance packages for small businesses and contractors. Our services include risk management consultation, policy customization, and claims support. Coverage options include property insurance, liability protection, cyber liability, and specialized industry-specific policies for contractors and landscapers.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance solutions include term and permanent policies with personalized financial planning. We offer needs assessments, policy comparisons, and estate planning assistance. Our advisors help clients protect dependents, cover debts, and create legacy plans through various insurance products.
Boat Insurance
We provide specialized insurance for watercraft including boats and yachts. Our marine insurance covers physical damage, liability, and emergency assistance. Our brokers help clients understand coverage options for different vessel types and usage patterns while securing competitive market rates.
People
William C. Steele
President
Third-generation insurance professional with 40+ years experience, continuing family legacy of personalized service and community commitment.
Mackenzie Steele
Office Manager/Producer
Insurance professional with specialized knowledge in policy administration and client services, maintaining family tradition of excellence.
Eric Pienkosz
Account Executive
Certified insurance professional with CIP, CAIB, and CRM designations, serving as Stoney Creek office representative since 2014.
Riley Steele
Producer
New generation team member trained under experienced family brokers, providing modern insurance solutions with traditional values.
Jane Haun
Life Insurance Advisor
Specialist in life insurance products with expertise in financial planning and estate protection strategies.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, commercial, boat, tenant, health, and specialty insurance products for personal and business clients.
How can I get an instant insurance quote?
Visit our website's quote section for immediate auto, motorcycle, home, condo, and tenant insurance quotes through our CSR24 portal.
Do you offer 24/7 claims reporting?
Yes, our electronic claims reporting system operates 24 hours a day, 7 days a week for emergency situations.
Are you a local insurance agency?
We operate from two Ontario locations in Port Colborne and Stoney Creek, serving Niagara Peninsula clients since 1898.
How does your policy customization work?
Our brokers assess individual needs and leverage multiple carrier options to create tailored insurance solutions for each client.
Can I manage policies online?
Yes, our CSR24 client portal allows policy management, document signing, and account access anytime through any device.