Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Lakeside Vacation at Colonial Bay Cottage Resort
Colonial Bay Cottage Resort has been a cherished lakeside destination since the early 1940s, offering guests a unique blend of traditional Muskoka hospitality and modern comforts. Founded by Mrs. Mary Brooks as Brooklyn Lodge, the resort has evolved through generations while maintaining its core values of family, relaxation, and connection to nature. Under the stewardship of Bruce and Nicolle Howell since 1994, weve preserved the charm of a small, three-season cottage resort that caters to families seeking authentic experiences. Our property, nestled on the shores of Peninsula Lake, provides a peaceful retreat with personalized service, ensuring every guest feels at home.With fewer than 40 guests at any time, visitors enjoy privacy and tranquility while accessing curated activities like water sports, campfires, and guided excursions. Our history of hospitality, combined with proximity to Algonquin Park and Huntsvilles amenities, makes Colonial Bay a timeless choice for creating lasting memories. We pride ourselves on balancing casual comfort with attentive service, ensuring every detailfrom air-conditioned accommodations to curated local partnershipsenhances your Muskoka escape.
Services
Cottage Rentals
Water Activities
Campfire Events
Day Trips
Golf Packages
Dining Reservations
Boat Rentals
Hiking Guides
Family Reunions
Winter Stays
Details
- Year established: 1940
Highlights and features
- Family-owned since 1940, offering personalized hospitality rooted in Muskoka tradition.
- Pet-free property with air-conditioned cottages and modern amenities for comfort.
- Direct lake access for swimming, kayaking, and standup paddleboarding on clean waters.
- Proximity to Algonquin Park, golf courses, and Huntsvilles shops and restaurants.
- Curated seasonal activities including campfires, corn roasts, and guided excursions.
What people say
Wonderful family reunion
Perfect vacation destination
Clean accommodations
Warm hospitality
Serene surroundings
Services
Cottage Rentals
Our cottages sleep 26 guests with queen, double, or single beds, private bathrooms, and modern amenities like satellite TV, Wi-Fi, and kitchenware. Select units feature fireplaces, lake views, and shaded decks for privacy. All cottages include propane barbecues and outdoor seating.
Water Activities
Enjoy swimming in our sand-bottom lakefront, kayaking, canoeing, standup paddleboarding, or rowboating. The resort provides life jackets, docks, and equipment storage. Children enjoy water trampolines and supervised play areas during peak seasons.
Campfire Events
Weekly campfires include marshmallow roasting, storytelling, and casual socializing. Fire pits are available for private use, with complimentary firewood and seating. Staff organize seasonal events like corn roasts and themed evenings.
Day Trips
Guided and self-guided trips to Algonquin Park (30 minutes away), Dorset Lookout Tower, and Santas Village. The resort provides maps, transportation tips, and partnerships with local tour operators for hiking, canoeing, and sightseeing.
Golf Packages
Nearby 18-hole courses like Deerhurst Highlands and Huntsville Downs, with discounted tee times for guests. The resort offers shuttle coordination, equipment storage, and partnerships with five courses within 15 minutes drive.
People
Bruce Howell
Owner
Bruce Howell co-owns Colonial Bay Cottage Resort with Nicolle Howell, continuing a family legacy in hospitality since 1969. He oversees operations and guest experiences, blending tradition with modern comforts.
Nicolle Howell
Owner
Nicolle Howell partners with Bruce to manage Colonial Bay Cottage Resort, focusing on guest relations and seasonal programming. Her leadership ensures the resort maintains its family-centric, welcoming atmosphere.
Questions
What types of accommodations are available?
We offer studio rooms, 1–3 bedroom cottages with kitchens, air conditioning, and private bathrooms. All units sleep 2–6 guests with flexible bedding options.
Are pets allowed at the resort?
No, Colonial Bay Resort is a pet-free property to ensure comfort for all guests and preserve our natural surroundings.
What activities are included with my stay?
Complimentary activities include swimming, canoeing, kayaking, campfires, and access to playgrounds. Seasonal events like corn roasts and guided hikes are also offered.
How far is the resort from Algonquin Park?
Colonial Bay Resort is 20 minutes (32 km) from Algonquin Park’s west gate, ideal for day trips featuring hiking, canoeing, and wildlife viewing.
Can I book a family reunion or group event?
Yes, our property accommodates family reunions and small groups, with flexible cottage layouts and communal spaces like picnic areas and fire pits.
What dining options are nearby?
On-site, enjoy self-catering in your cottage. Nearby options include Muskoka On The Rocks Restaurant (across the road) and Henrietta’s Pine Bakery (10 minutes away).
Reviews (7)
Vanessa Magee
Nov 21, 2021
Report
Lovedniy!. Excellent hosts and beaitiful spot. My 3 and 5 uear oldngirls had a ball jumping off the dock.
Clarence Chu
Oct 24, 2021
Report
The cottages though a bit small, it is nice and clean. The service is good and friendly. Guests can enjoy it's private dock with peddle boat and canoe and fishing. The view of the lake at sunset is beautiful.
Yong Ho Kim Joseph
Oct 21, 2021
Report
The scenary was great! Stayed here on a cloudy day, a little disappointed with the weather, but turned out to be good. The lakeside scenary was still picturesque despite the gloomy weather, offering an amazing atmosphere to relax at. Moreover, a great place for a barbeque or picnic.The room was clean and the place is in vicinity to other attractions, being in between Huntsville and Algonquin.
Omkar Paradkar
Sep 13, 2021
Report
I recently visited this cottage on Sep 2021 Labour Day long weekend. It was an amazing experience. The surroundings are naturally rich and very scenic. The atmosphere is very peaceful and serene. All COVID-19 protocols were followed. The Staff is very friendly and welcoming. All in all, excellent place to stay.
Peter
Aug 23, 2021
Report
Stayed there August 16-17
It was a great little get away for the family. The grounds were super clean and the water front was amazing. Free use of all kayaks, paddle boats and canoes are available. The cottage is simple but clean and the beds are very comfortable. The kids and I had an amazing time and the owners are great friendly people. Highly recommend
It was a great little get away for the family. The grounds were super clean and the water front was amazing. Free use of all kayaks, paddle boats and canoes are available. The cottage is simple but clean and the beds are very comfortable. The kids and I had an amazing time and the owners are great friendly people. Highly recommend
Susan Middleton
Aug 19, 2021
Report
A great place for a relaxing holiday. Something for all ages. Clean comfortable and quiet. Responsive and caring hosts who's long experience of welcoming vacationers to their beautiful lakeside property makes for an excellent experience.
Bernard Miguel
Jul 12, 2021
Report
Very clean! Owners were very nice, they took time to chat with us by the water. Definitely going back and will be recommending to our friends and family