Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza & Pub Favorites in St. Catharines
Founded on the principles of authentic Italian cuisine and family tradition, Pie Guys Pizzeria has become a beloved local staple since its inception. Our commitment to handcrafted ingredients, from in-house dough to homemade sauces and dressings, ensures every meal reflects our dedication to quality. With multiple locations across St. Catharines, Niagara Falls, and Fonthill, we combine neighborhood charm with modern convenience, offering dine-in, takeout, and delivery services.Recognized for excellence through annual 'Best Pizza of the Year' awards, our team prioritizes customer loyalty through friendly service and a family-friendly atmosphere complete with full bars and heated patios. As a franchise, we maintain rigorous consistency in recipes and service standards while adapting to the unique needs of each community we serve.
Services
Pizza Delivery
Dine-In Restaurant
Takeout Orders
Full Bar Service
Private Events
Highlights and features
- We use authentic Italian family recipes for all our dishes.
- Multiple locations offer consistent quality and service.
- Award-winning pizza recognized by the city of St. Catharines.
- Family-friendly atmosphere with full bar and heated patio.
- Commitment to exceptional customer service and community values.
Services
Pizza Delivery
Our pizza delivery service brings fresh, handcrafted Italian-style pizzas directly to your door. Available at all four Ontario locations, we ensure hot, timely delivery of our award-winning recipes, including specialty pies, wings, and daily specials. Perfect for family dinners or casual gatherings.
Dine-In Restaurant
Experience our family-friendly restaurant atmosphere featuring a full bar, heated patio, and two large projection screens. Located at the Mac Turnbull Drive location, this hub offers an extensive menu of pizzas, burgers, salads, and desserts in a welcoming environment for all ages.
Takeout Orders
Convenient takeout service available at all locations for our full menu of pizzas, wings, and daily specials. Ideal for busy schedules or enjoying our homemade recipes at home. Place orders online or by phone for quick, contactless pickup.
Full Bar Service
Our full-service bars offer a selection of domestic and imported beers, wines, and cocktails. Complement your meal with craft brews, classic drinks, or our signature Buffalo Chicken Pizza paired with Franks hot sauce and blue cheese.
Private Events
Host special occasions or gatherings in our spacious dining areas. With projection screens, ample seating, and customizable menus, our locations provide the perfect backdrop for birthdays, sports viewing parties, or corporate events.
Questions
What are Pie Guys Pizzeria's operating hours?
We’re open Monday-Thursday 12pm-9pm/10pm, Friday-Saturday 12pm-10pm, and Sunday 12pm-9pm, varying slightly by location.
Do you offer delivery and takeout options?
Yes, all four locations provide both delivery and takeout services for our full menu, including pizza, wings, and daily specials.
Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
Yes, we offer gluten-free or keto-friendly crust upgrades for any 8-slice pizza at an additional $6 charge.
What awards has Pie Guys Pizzeria won?
We’ve received multiple 'Best Pizza of the Year' awards from the city of St. Catharines for our authentic Italian recipes.
Do you have vegetarian or specialty pizza options?
Yes, our menu includes vegetarian pizzas like the Mediterranean Pie and customizable options with premium toppings.
Can I host a private event at Pie Guys?
Yes, our locations feature spaces for private events with projection screens, full bar access, and tailored menu options.
Reviews (7)
Ross Allen
Jan 24, 2022
Report
Grab the wing deal on Thursday! Might be the biggest wings in St. Kitts. Also make sure you try the Cajun... salt & pepper with a touch of Cajun heat.
Jo Ey
Dec 20, 2021
Report
I've always liked Pie Guys Pizza. The staff is pleasant and it top of the line pizza. However it has gone down hill and the prices have sky rocketed. I've reduced my times of ordering there due to prices and not being ready on time mostly. I had just ordered another pizza there and was told 30 mins. I got there in 30 mins and was told "it will just be a few more minutes" and to wait in my car. I proceeded to wait for another 31 mins. Clearly the pizza wasn't even put in oven when I was told a few
more minutes. I'm not one to complain or make scene. (maybe I should have) but I dont like confrontation
more minutes. I'm not one to complain or make scene. (maybe I should have) but I dont like confrontation
Mandy Wright
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Bought 3lbs of chicken wings tonight. The bag was so light (even with the celery, carrots and dip), that I immediately went home and weighed the portions. I understand they may be weighed in a raw state, but… when you lose over half the weight, and only end up with 7 wings per portion, that was really off-putting. Unfortunately they were dry too so felt a bit ripped off for almost $40 after tax. I don't want to go as far as saying not to recommend trying them (taste was good), but Facebook doesn't give an in between option.
Carly Megan
Dec 02, 2021
Report
We live in the neighbour hood and went in tonight for our anniversary! Wasn’t aware of the specials but LOVED the date night deal! Amazing food and can’t wait to come back :)
Anita Engelage
Nov 10, 2021
Report
Ordered the Works pizza and it was delicious. Wings were the best. Delivered before the estimated time. First time ordering, but won't be the last. Great job Pie Guys.
Rrr Lll
Sep 23, 2021
Report
Pizza Wings steak subs all delicious....... I'm 61 years old it's the best wings pizza and steak sub I've ever had in my entire life so I contacted the owner........ He said it will not compromise on the ingredients....... Amazing absolutely amazing food.......... Thanks pie guys you'll be seeing a lot of me
Don Bartley
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Great pizza and wings unfortunately they just cant seem to figure out the busy times. If its going to be an hour and a half then just say so. The most infuriating thing is being told 45 minutes then wait in the parking lot another 45 minutes. Would happily wait in the comfort of my home until its actually ready. Spoke to many people in the parking lot while waiting and all said the same thing. Were done as its happened too many times. Sorry guys, figure it out and Im sure youll be the pizza place in town. Bye bye