Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Guelph, ON
At Dumfries Mutual Insurance, we have dedicated ourselves to safeguarding communities through personalized insurance solutions since 1856. Our customer-centric approach ensures that every policy reflects our commitment to protecting families, businesses, and what matters most to our members. With over 160 years of combined experience and a team of more than 90 professionals, we prioritize community engagement, innovation, and reliability in every interaction. Our merger with Halwell Mutual and Dumfries Mutual in 2024 marks a new era of excellence, expanding our ability to serve over 30,000 members with tailored home, auto, commercial, contractor, and farm insurance products. We emphasize transparency, ethical practices, and proactive risk management to build lasting trust.

Our board and senior leadership bring decades of industry expertise, ensuring we maintain the highest standards of service and accountability. By focusing on local needs and fostering a forward-thinking workplace, we aim to redefine mutual insurance as a force for community resilience. Our dedication to continuous improvement drives us to exceed expectations, whether through bundled policy savings, 24/7 claims support, or digital tools like the HD Connect App. We measure success by the peace of mind we provide, backed by our promise to make insurance better for every client. This legacy of trust and innovation positions us as a leader in mutual insurance, setting benchmarks for reliability and customer satisfaction.
Services
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Commercial Insurance Contractor Insurance Farm Insurance Insurance Bundles Claims Support Loss Prevention Policy Management Digital Tools
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 160 years of combined insurance expertise rooted in community service.
  • Our policies are tailored to protect homes, businesses, and farms with personalized coverage.
  • We prioritize customer-centric solutions through local agent partnerships and digital tools.
  • Our merger in 2024 strengthens our ability to deliver innovative, reliable insurance products.
  • We maintain a team of 90+ professionals dedicated to ethical, transparent service.
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance policies protect properties ranging from single-family homes to cottages, covering structural damage, personal belongings, and liability risks. We offer customizable plans to suit urban and rural lifestyles, ensuring financial security against unforeseen events. With flexible payment options and 24/7 claims support, we prioritize swift resolution and peace of mind for homeowners.
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance for cars, trucks, and motorcycles, including collision coverage, liability protection, and roadside assistance. Our policies adapt to diverse driving needs, from daily commutes to commercial use. By partnering with local agents, we ensure personalized advice and competitive rates tailored to individual driving records and vehicle types.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance safeguards businesses against property damage, liability claims, and income loss due to disruptions. Tailored policies address industry-specific risks for retailers, manufacturers, and service providers. We emphasize risk management strategies and customizable deductibles to align with business goals, supported by dedicated claims specialists for rapid incident resolution.
Contractor Insurance
Designed for tradespeople, this coverage protects tools, equipment, and job sites from theft, damage, or liability claims. Policies include general liability, tools and equipment coverage, and income protection for project delays. We collaborate with contractors to create cost-effective solutions that support project success and long-term business stability.
Farm Insurance
Our farm insurance plans address risks for hobby farms to large-scale operations, covering barns, livestock, crops, and machinery. Customizable policies adapt to seasonal challenges and property size, including liability protection for farm visitors. We combine industry expertise with localized knowledge to ensure comprehensive safeguards for agricultural livelihoods.
People
Rocco Neglia
Chief Executive Officer
Rocco Neglia leads Dumfries Mutual Insurance with a focus on strategic growth and community engagement, leveraging decades of insurance industry leadership to drive innovation and member satisfaction.
Tom Seaman
Chief Operations Officer
Tom Seaman oversees daily operations, ensuring efficient service delivery and implementation of HD Mutual's community-focused insurance solutions through process optimization and team development.
Harry Bryant
Chair
Harry Bryant chairs the board, guiding HD Mutual's governance and long-term vision with extensive experience in mutual insurance and a commitment to member-centric values.
Lynda Crickmore
Vice-Chair
Lynda Crickmore supports strategic oversight as Vice-Chair, contributing industry expertise and advocacy for community-driven insurance practices that align with HD Mutual's mission.
Nate DeJonge
Chief Financial Officer
Nate DeJonge manages financial strategy and stability, ensuring HD Mutual maintains strong fiscal health while delivering value to policyholders through responsible resource management.
Questions
What types of insurance does HD Mutual offer?
We provide home, auto, commercial, contractor, and farm insurance, along with policy bundles for combined savings.
Can I manage my policy online?
Yes, use our HD Connect App for digital policy management, payments, and claims submission.
Do you offer discounts for bundled policies?
Yes, bundling home and auto insurance or other policies provides significant savings and convenience.
How do I file a claim?
Submit a claim online through our portal or contact your local agent for assistance with loss documentation.
What areas does HD Mutual serve?
We primarily serve Guelph, Sheffield, and surrounding regions in Ontario, Canada.
Reviews (4)
Jim Zettel
Sep 25, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Hi I have been a client for 20 years, Collen Kiriakos has been my Agent since Clare Logel retired. She is very professional as well as Clare was.
Barbara Dixon
Mar 20, 2021 Report
After over 40 years with our previous insurance company (and no claims), we decided to look for a new company as the feeling of being a valued customer went away rapidly when our previous insurer was bought out. Less and less driving due to COVID-19 and a pittance of a refund for 2 months, the rates just kept rising but we got emails about how valued we are. That added insult to injury! Anyway, we found Dumfries Mutual, contacted Christina George, and the rest is history so to speak. Christina explained everything very clearly, was extremely helpful and professional. Added bonus is that the policies
Juleeya Daly
Dec 31, 2019 Report
I've been with Glen for almost 10 years. He's always been prompt in answering my questions and helping me get things set up that I required. I HIGHLY recommend this company and even moreso, him .
Deb At MorkieNation
Oct 22, 2019 Report
I feel fortunate to have Dumfries Mutual Insurance - so trustworthy, fair and reliable. No nonsense if you have a claim. This is what insurance used to be like - and still is at Dumfries. Great people.