Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Northern Ontario Since 1975
Paul Ayotte Insurance Broker has been a trusted provider of comprehensive insurance solutions since 1975. As a family-owned and operated business, we have built a reputation for excellence across Northern Ontario through our five strategically located offices. Our team of experienced professionals is dedicated to delivering personalized service, combining deep industry knowledge with a commitment to understanding each client's unique needs. We offer a full range of insurance products, including auto, home, business, cottage, leisure lifestyle, and watercraft coverage, tailored to protect individuals and businesses alike. With decades of local expertise and strong partnerships with leading insurers, we ensure our clients receive competitive rates and customized protection.

Our focus on exceptional customer service has earned us long-term relationships with families and businesses throughout the region. We pride ourselves on being accessible, responsive, and committed to resolving claims efficiently. From our headquarters in Cochrane to our branch offices in Kirkland Lake, Mindemoya, Sudbury, and Haileybury, we remain dedicated to serving our community. Our brokers combine technical expertise with a personal touch, ensuring clients understand their coverage options and make informed decisions. For over 45 years, our mission has remained unchanged: to provide reliable insurance solutions while maintaining the highest standards of professionalism and client care.
Services
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Cottage Insurance Business Insurance Leisure Lifestyle Insurance Watercraft Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1975
Highlights and features
  • We have over 45 years of experience serving Northern Ontario communities.
  • Our team offers personalized insurance solutions tailored to individual needs.
  • We maintain strong partnerships with leading insurance providers.
  • Our brokers provide expert guidance through the claims process.
  • We operate five conveniently located offices across Northern Ontario.
What people say
Great service Cheapest rates Professional brokers Quick claims process Long-term trust
Services
Auto Insurance
Auto insurance provides essential protection for vehicle owners in Ontario. Our policies meet legal requirements while offering comprehensive coverage options for accidents, theft, and property damage. We help clients select appropriate liability limits and additional protections based on individual driving needs and vehicle value.
Home Insurance
Home insurance protects residential properties against common risks including fire, water damage, and theft. We offer customizable policies for primary residences, rental properties, and high-value homes. Our brokers help clients understand coverage options for building structures, personal belongings, and liability protection.
Business Insurance
Business insurance combines liability protection with property coverage for commercial operations. Our business owners' policies protect against common risks including property damage, liability claims, and business interruption. We tailor coverage to meet specific industry needs while helping businesses manage risk effectively.
Cottage Insurance
Cottage insurance provides specialized protection for seasonal and rental properties. Our policies address unique risks associated with secondary residences, including extended periods of vacancy and seasonal weather conditions. We offer coverage options for both high-value vacation homes and rental properties.
Watercraft Insurance
Watercraft insurance protects boat owners against damage and liability risks. Our policies cover various types of watercraft including motorboats, sailboats, and personal watercraft. We provide customized coverage options for both recreational and specialty water vehicles, ensuring protection on Northern Ontario's lakes and waterways.
People
Martin Ayotte
President
Martin Ayotte leads our team with over 40 years of insurance industry experience. He ensures our family-owned business maintains its commitment to personalized service while adapting to evolving client needs.
Chantal Ayotte
Broker
Chantal Ayotte brings extensive insurance expertise to our Cochrane office. With deep knowledge of Northern Ontario's unique insurance requirements, she helps clients find optimal coverage solutions tailored to their specific needs.
Bill Holmes
Branch Manager
Bill Holmes oversees our Sudbury operations with a focus on client satisfaction. His 25+ years in the insurance industry ensure our Sudbury clients receive expert guidance and comprehensive protection options.
Darryl Van Horn
Branch Manager
Darryl Van Horn manages our Mindemoya office with a commitment to personalized service. His local expertise helps residents and businesses in this area secure appropriate insurance coverage for their specific circumstances.
Lindsay Farrell
Team Lead/Broker
Lindsay Farrell serves as Team Lead and Broker in our Kirkland Lake office. With specialized knowledge in both personal and commercial insurance, she provides comprehensive risk management solutions to local clients.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, business, cottage, leisure lifestyle, and watercraft insurance solutions tailored to Northern Ontario residents and businesses.
How can I file an insurance claim?
Contact your broker during business hours or use our 24-hour claim numbers for partner insurers. Have your policy number ready when reporting.
Do you offer coverage outside Northern Ontario?
While our offices serve Northern Ontario communities, we can provide insurance solutions for clients throughout the province.
Are your insurance rates competitive?
We work with multiple insurers to ensure our clients receive competitive rates while maintaining comprehensive coverage options.
Can I get a quote online?
Visit our website to request a quote or contact your local office for personalized insurance recommendations and pricing.
Reviews (3)
Tracey Riley
Jul 24, 2021 Report
Called 3 times. 1sr call found out my agent no longer works there. Last 2 calls never received a call back from my agent. Would change companies if not such a hsssle
P. S.
Feb 22, 2021 Report
Quick, caring service by Celeste Tonkin @ PAIB. Thank you Celeste you always deliver reassurance with do able options. Paula-Jo
Wendy Rochon
Jul 21, 2018 Report
Very helpful staff...Celeste was understanding and thorough in getting me the best possible quote. Thank you PAIB