Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
46 Years
experience
Your Trusted Partner for Historic Fine Dining and Weddings in Mulmur
Established in 1980, Mrs Mitchell's operates from a meticulously restored 19th-century schoolhouse, honoring the legacy of its namesake, a dedicated local educator. Our establishment combines historic charm with modern culinary excellence, offering guests an immersive dining experience rooted in tradition and quality. We specialize in seasonal, locally sourced cuisine prepared with simple yet refined techniques that highlight natural flavors. Our team has over four decades of collective experience curating memorable events, from intimate weddings to celebratory gatherings, within our unique venue featuring lush gardens and architectural heritage.

We maintain rigorous standards in both food preparation and service delivery, ensuring every guest receives attentive care and consistently exceptional meals. Our commitment to excellence extends to accommodating special dietary needs and providing personalized event planning assistance, reflecting our dedication to customer satisfaction and community engagement.
Services
Fine Dining Wedding Services Special Events Gift Certificates Catering
Details
  • Year established: 1980
Highlights and features
  • We offer 40+ years of experience in historic venue hospitality and event planning
  • Our restored 1889 schoolhouse provides a unique, picturesque setting for celebrations
  • We accommodate special dietary requirements without compromising flavor or presentation
  • Our team includes certified event professionals with expertise in wedding coordination
  • We received the Best Restaurant award from the Hills of Headwaters Tourism Association
Services
Fine Dining
Our fine dining experience features locally sourced ingredients prepared with simple techniques that highlight natural flavors. Guests enjoy seasonal menus in a casually upscale atmosphere with colonial decor. The four-course meals include house specialties like our famous garlic dressing and warm crusty rolls, complemented by an extensive wine list.
Wedding Services
We specialize in romantic country weddings with both indoor and outdoor venues. Our services include ceremony coordination, reception planning, and customized menus for up to 75 guests. The restored schoolhouse and perennial gardens provide picturesque backdrops for ceremonies, cocktail hours, and photo sessions.
Special Events
We host milestone celebrations including anniversaries, birthdays, and corporate functions. Our small function dinner menu accommodates groups of 14+ with prix fixe options. The venue features live music performances and themed events like Christmas floral demonstrations and bridal dinners.
Gift Certificates
Gift certificates are available in any denomination for special occasions. Recipients can redeem them for fine dining experiences, wedding services, or special events. We offer direct mailing services for purchased certificates with personalized messages.
Catering
Our catering services provide homemade meals for events with dietary restrictions. Options include appetizers, entrees, and desserts tailored to client preferences. We offer menu customization for weddings and special functions with professional event coordination.
People
Maureen Baufeldt
Founder
Maureen Baufeldt founded Mrs Mitchell's in 1980, honoring the legacy of the school's longest-serving teacher. She established the restaurant's reputation for quality and hospitality until her passing in 2011.
Heidi Baufeldt
Owner
Heidi Baufeldt has operated Mrs Mitchell's since 2011, continuing her mother's tradition of excellence. She brings over 30 years of hospitality experience and maintains the establishment's commitment to quality and personalized service.
Questions
What wedding services do you offer?
We provide full-service wedding coordination including venue selection, menu customization, and event planning for up to 75 guests in our historic schoolhouse and gardens.
What are your restaurant hours?
We serve lunch Tuesday-Friday 12pm-2pm, brunch Saturday-Sunday 11am-2pm, and dinner Tuesday-Sunday 5pm-close. Closed Mondays.
Do you accommodate dietary restrictions?
Yes, we accommodate special dietary requirements with advance notice and offer menu modifications to ensure all guests enjoy their meals.
Can I purchase gift certificates?
Yes, we offer gift certificates in any amount with direct mailing available for special occasions and celebrations.
What makes your venue unique?
Our restored 1889 schoolhouse features colonial architecture, lush perennial gardens, and historic charm creating a distinctive setting for dining and events.
Do you host corporate events?
Yes, we host business functions and staff parties with customized menus and event planning services for groups of 14+ people.
Reviews (7)
Jo-Anne Gibson
Jan 02, 2022 Report
A local favourite but overrated eatery and a disappointing experience today. Although one of our party arrived 7 minutes late it took us 30 minutes to be asked for our beverage order. By that time, we were ready to order our food but were told another server would come for our food order. Food was fine, signature mushroom soup slightly bland. Finished our meal and were presented with our bill. Then had to ask for tea which seemed to be an inconvenience. Within minutes after settling the bill and finishing our tea we were told by our server the table was reserved for another luncheon . We left.
Jeff Miller
Dec 30, 2021 Report
Great food, excellent service, customer friendly atmosphere, reasonable prices. Couldn’t ask for more.
Liz Cowie
Dec 29, 2021 Report
Beautiful restaurant
Very festive. Our server was extremely friendly and helpful. The food was very very good . Well worth the price .
Stephanie Galt
Dec 17, 2021 Report
A true gem of a restaurant located inside an old schoolhouse! Their holiday decorations are so elegant and festive - every detail was absolutely beautiful. Went for brunch and my French toast was fantastic, as was their famed mushroom soup. A basket of biscuits/muffins is brought to each table before you order, which is a nice touch. Highly recommend this place! My only suggestion/area for improvement is that they use an online service like OpenTable for taking reservations. Their current policy is that you have to call and leave a message requesting a date and time, then someone calls you back
Jeremy Muehlbacher
Dec 03, 2021 Report
What can I say........Heidi and her amazing staff made my wedding day everything, I wanted it to be. The service is beyond any I have had before at any restaurant. Thank you for making our day special.
Bob Fraser
Nov 02, 2021 Report
The restaurant ambiance is very classy yet comfortable. The friendly and efficient wait staff really helped make our dining experience enjoyable. As always, the food was top notch. We had the meat loaf and sole - both were fantastic.
Britta
Nov 02, 2021 Report
Always a great experience. My family and I have enjoyed going to this restaurant for over 30+ years. The food has always been consitent - great tasting and good portions. The service is friendly and good. The outdoor dining was a great addition. Pricing is reasonalbe for this type of dining.