Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Markham, ON
Guthrie Insurance Brokers has been a trusted name in the insurance industry since 1962, dedicated to providing personalized and comprehensive insurance solutions for Canadian families and businesses. As a 100% Canadian-owned company, we combine decades of experience with a client-first approach, ensuring our clients receive tailored coverage that aligns with their unique needs. Our team of RIBO licensed and bonded professionals prioritizes transparency, accountability, and expert advice, representing top Canadian insurers to deliver competitive rates and unparalleled service.

We specialize in multi-policy packages to eliminate coverage gaps and maximize savings, while our 24/7 claims support ensures clients are never left without assistance. With a legacy of fostering long-term relationships, we remain committed to simplifying insurance through a blend of innovation, personalized service, and a deep understanding of our clients' financial security needs.
Services
Personal Auto Insurance Home Insurance Commercial Insurance Life Insurance Boat Insurance Classic Car Insurance Cyber Crime Insurance Travel Insurance Group Benefits Insurance Private Client Services
Details
  • Year established: 1962
Highlights and features
  • We offer over 50 years of experience in personalized insurance solutions.
  • Our team provides 24/7 claims support and client-focused advocacy.
  • We guarantee competitive premiums with unique discounts like smart home telematics.
  • Our multi-policy packages eliminate coverage gaps and maximize savings.
  • As RIBO licensed brokers, we are legally accountable to prioritize client needs.
Associations and certifications
  • RIBO
What people say
Trusted adviser Stellar service Prompt resolution Professional and polite Highly recommend
Services
Personal Auto Insurance
Personal Auto Insurance protects individual drivers against financial loss from accidents, theft, or damage. Our policies include liability coverage, collision protection, and optional add-ons like roadside assistance. Clients benefit from competitive premiums, telematics-based discounts, and personalized support to ensure adequate coverage tailored to their driving habits and needs.
Home Insurance
Home Insurance safeguards homeowners against risks like fire, theft, and natural disasters. We offer customizable policies covering property damage, personal belongings, and liability claims. Clients receive expert guidance to select appropriate coverage limits, discounts for smart home features, and 24/7 claims assistance to expedite recovery after incidents.
Commercial Insurance
Commercial Insurance provides tailored risk management solutions for businesses, including liability coverage, property protection, and specialized policies like cyber crime or directors and officers insurance. Our brokers assess each business's unique needs to ensure comprehensive protection, competitive pricing, and compliance with industry regulations.
Life Insurance
Life Insurance offers financial security to beneficiaries upon the policyholder's death. We provide term and permanent life policies, mortgage protection, and living benefits options. Clients receive personalized advice to align coverage with their estate planning goals and family needs, ensuring long-term financial stability.
Boat Insurance
Boat Insurance protects watercraft owners from damages, liability claims, and theft. Policies cover vessels used for recreation or commercial purposes, with options for trailer coverage and emergency assistance. Our brokers help clients navigate specific risks associated with boating to ensure adequate protection on the water.
Questions
What types of insurance does Guthrie Insurance Brokers offer?
We provide personal, commercial, and group insurance, including auto, home, life, boat, cyber crime, and specialized commercial coverage.
How does Guthrie Insurance Brokers differ from direct insurers?
As RIBO licensed brokers, we prioritize client needs, offering personalized advice and access to multiple insurers for competitive rates and tailored coverage.
What should I do if I need to file a claim?
Contact us immediately for 24/7 claims support; our team will guide you through the process and advocate for a fair, prompt settlement.
Do you serve areas outside the GTA?
Yes, we serve all of the GTA, Durham Region, Kawarthas, Northumberland, and Alberta.
Can I get a discount on multiple policies?
Yes, our multi-policy packages ensure no missed discounts, gaps, or overlaps, maximizing savings for our clients.
Reviews (6)
Navroz Esmail
Jan 27, 2022 Report
I have been dealing with Jeff Clarkson over at Guthrie Insurance for some time now, and I must say his professionalism and client support is like no other... I have had dealings with other agents and firms in the past, and these guys set the bar!!!! Extremely pleased with Jeff and Guthrie Insurance!!!!!
Amandeep Vaid
Oct 26, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Responsiveness
Shaan and Neil we're wonderful - very responsive, thorough, and provided excellent service. They were able to find and secure auto insurance that met all my needs at a very competitive rate within 24 hours. Highly recommended!
Als Double Play
Oct 01, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism
We have been clients of Guthrie Insurance Brokers for the last five years and are very pleased with the professional service we have received. Our advisor is always prompt and provides sound advice. We are very happy with Guthrie!
Sumedh Kulkarni
Sep 26, 2021 Report
I was preparing to move into a new condo and Shaan from Guthrie Brokers helped me throughout the entire process, from start to finish. He was able to give me excellent coverage and also saved me a sizeable chunk of cash when I paired my auto and condo insurance together. He answered all my questions without any delay and kept me informed on any details I may have missed. Thank you so much, Shaan! I really appreciate your help!
Sonia Malik
Jun 01, 2021 Report
I was referred to Guthrie Insurance through a client of mine, Jeff was my direct contact. I bought 2 rentals last year and he was absolutely awesome and the turn around was amazing. This year with my third rental it was also excellent. The response is within the same day, he is efficient and I don't need to worry about any details. He has me covered. So happy with this company :)
Sonia Pak
May 10, 2021 Report
Positive:Professionalism,Quality,Responsiveness,Value
Our broker was Agnes Wong. She was tremendous. We were desperate to get coverage when all other companies rejected us outright. But Agnes, determined to save our home and pets, got us two offers!! She's our heroine. We appreciate all her efforts and are so grateful for her assistance.