Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
41 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Aurora, Ontario
Founded in 1985, Choice Insurance Brokers has established itself as a trusted provider of comprehensive insurance solutions for Ontario families and businesses. Our independent brokerage offers personalized service across personal insurance, commercial insurance, and specialty coverage. With a team of experienced professionals, we prioritize client needs while maintaining the highest standards of integrity and expertise. Our commitment to excellence has earned us a reputation as a reliable partner in risk management.

We continuously adapt to industry innovations while preserving the core values that have defined our success since inception. Our brokers work closely with clients to understand unique requirements and deliver tailored protection strategies. Through strategic growth and leadership continuity, we remain dedicated to serving Aurora and surrounding communities with unwavering professionalism.
Services
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Commercial Insurance Business Insurance Specialty Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1985
Highlights and features
  • Over 35 years of experience in insurance solutions
  • Tailored coverage for personal and commercial needs
  • Trusted by Aurora residents since 1985
  • Independent brokerage with multiple carrier options
  • Experienced team with specialized industry knowledge
Services
Home Insurance
Our home insurance solutions protect primary residences, condominiums, rental properties, and seasonal homes. Coverage includes property damage protection, liability coverage, and additional living expenses. We offer specialized options like excess umbrella liability and home business endorsements to meet diverse client needs.
Auto Insurance
We provide comprehensive auto insurance for personal vehicles, business use vehicles, and specialty vehicles including antiques and recreational vehicles. Coverage includes liability protection, collision coverage, and optional enhancements like excess umbrella liability for complete road protection.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance packages protect businesses with property coverage, general liability, and business interruption insurance. We offer specialized plans for manufacturers, real estate owners, wholesalers, and professional services with customizable options for U.S. operations and product liability.
Specialty Insurance
We provide specialized insurance solutions including directors & officers liability, surety bonds, and event-specific coverage. Our offerings include contractor bonds, commercial surety, and unique programs for hobby clubs and liquor liability requirements.
Risk Management
Our brokers offer comprehensive risk assessment and mitigation strategies for both personal and commercial clients. Services include policy reviews, coverage gap analysis, and customized protection plans to address specific risk exposures.
People
Bill Collyer
Owner
Co-owner with extensive insurance industry experience since purchasing the brokerage in 2014. Focuses on strategic growth and client relationships.
Jeff Hitchin
Owner
Co-owner and key leader since 2014 acquisition. Brings deep insurance expertise and commitment to personalized service.
Mike Grabowski
Commercial Insurance Specialist
Founder who continues supporting commercial clients. Over 35 years of experience in business insurance solutions.
Josh Dahmer
Insurance Broker
Experienced broker providing personalized insurance solutions. Specializes in connecting clients with appropriate coverage options.
Scott Collyer
Insurance Professional
Dedicated insurance expert serving client needs with comprehensive knowledge of personal and commercial insurance products.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We offer home, auto, commercial, business, and specialty insurance including surety bonds and directors & officers liability coverage.
Do you serve businesses outside Aurora?
Yes, we serve businesses throughout Ontario and provide coverage options for U.S. operations and cross-border requirements.
Can I get coverage for specialty vehicles?
Yes, we insure antique vehicles, recreational vehicles, motorcycles, ATVs, snowmobiles, and pleasure watercraft.
Do you offer business insurance for manufacturers?
Yes, we provide specialized manufacturing insurance covering property damage, liability, and business interruption with U.S. sales coverage options.
Are you an independent insurance agency?
Yes, as an independent brokerage we offer multiple carrier options to find the best coverage for your specific needs.
Reviews (1)
Krista Noble
Apr 29, 2015 Report
Fantastic, reliable customer service. Josh makes all of his clients a priority, making every possible effort to get them the best possible rates and coverage for their needs.