Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
41 Years
experience
Expert Jewelry Appraisal Services in Hamilton
Founded in 1985, Jewellery Judge has established itself as Canada's premier destination for professional jewelry appraisal services. Our team of credentialed experts, led by industry veteran Steven A. Knight, combines decades of experience with cutting-edge technology to deliver precise, reliable valuations. We pioneered the 'While You Watch' appraisal method, ensuring complete transparency and client participation throughout the process. Our appraisals adhere to the highest industry standards, supported by affiliations with the Gemological Institute of America and the Canadian Jewellers Association. With a focus on education and customer empowerment, we provide detailed documentation and market research to inform every client decision.

Our services extend beyond valuation to include expert witness testimony and gemstone analysis, serving both individual clients and legal professionals. Jewellery Judge maintains a comprehensive database of over a million diamond and colored stone prices to ensure accurate, up-to-date valuations. Our commitment to ethical practices and continuous professional development has earned us recognition as Canada's favorite jewelry appraiser. We operate from our flagship location in Hamilton's historic Locke Street South District, serving clients locally and nationally.
Services
Jewelry Appraisal Insurance Valuation Estate Planning Gemstone Grading Expert Witness Computer-Assisted Appraisals Precious Metal Testing Diamond Analysis Colored Stone Evaluation Appraisal Documentation
Details
  • Year established: 1985
Highlights and features
  • We pioneered the 'While You Watch' appraisal method ensuring complete transparency
  • Our appraisals utilize a database of over 1 million current diamond/colored stone prices
  • Founder Steven Knight developed Canada's first computer-assisted appraisal system
  • Recognized expert appraiser featured on CBC Marketplace and CTV News
  • Maintain strict ethical standards with affiliations to top industry organizations
Associations and certifications
  • Gemological Institute of America
  • Canadian Jewellers Association
  • American Gem Trade Association
What people say
Expert appraisal Vast knowledge Impressed efficiency Honest expert appraisal Fantastic experience
Services
Jewelry Appraisal
Our comprehensive jewelry appraisals provide accurate retail replacement values for insurance purposes. Using computer-assisted technology and a database of over a million current prices, we evaluate each piece's gemstones, metal quality, and design elements. Our 'While You Watch' process allows clients to observe the entire appraisal while receiving detailed explanations about their jewelry's characteristics and market value.
Gemstone Grading
We offer precise grading for diamonds and colored gemstones using industry-standard methodologies. Our Graduate Gemologist evaluates cut, color, clarity, and carat weight while considering market factors that affect value. The process includes non-destructive testing and comparison against master diamond sets to ensure accurate, reliable assessments that meet insurance and legal requirements.
Expert Witness
Steven Knight provides expert testimony for jewelry valuation in legal matters including estate disputes and insurance claims. With extensive court experience and accepted appraisal methodologies, we deliver technically sound evidence supported by comprehensive documentation. Our services include court-ready reports and professional testimony based on decades of industry expertise.
Computer-Assisted Appraisals
Our proprietary system combines traditional appraisal techniques with advanced technology for enhanced accuracy. The computer database tracks current market prices across multiple categories while maintaining detailed records of past appraisals. This approach ensures consistent, verifiable valuations with digital documentation that meets insurance industry standards and simplifies future re-evaluations.
Precious Metal Testing
We conduct non-destructive precious metal testing using state-of-the-art equipment to determine karat purity and composition. Our Vanta GX Precious Metal Analyzer provides instant results without damaging items, making it ideal for evaluating jewelry, coins, and bullion. The process includes verification of hallmarks and comparison against current market prices for accurate valuation.
People
Steven A. Knight
Founder & Lead Appraiser
Graduate Gemologist with 40+ years experience, inventor of Canada's first computer-assisted appraisal system, and recognized expert featured on CBC and CTV. Holds RMV and CJA-CAP accreditations.
Questions
What types of appraisals do you provide?
We specialize in insurance replacement appraisals, estate valuations, and expert witness services for jewelry and gemstones.
How long does an appraisal take?
Most appraisals complete in 15-30 minutes with our efficient 'While You Watch' process.
Are your appraisals accepted by insurance companies?
Yes, our detailed reports meet industry standards and are accepted by all major insurers.
Do you buy jewelry?
We focus exclusively on impartial appraisals and do not engage in jewelry sales or purchases.
Can you appraise inherited jewelry?
Yes, we frequently evaluate estate jewelry with historical or sentimental value.
What credentials do your appraisers hold?
Our lead appraiser maintains Graduate Gemologist (GIA), RMV, and CJA-CAP accreditations.
Reviews (1)
Judith P.
Nov 03, 2017 Report
" Pleasantly Surprised "

I found Mr. Steven Knight, the proprietor to most pleasant, engaged and very knowledgeable, not to mention a very reasonable fee for my documented appraisal. He saved me a good deal of money, exposing my purchase as a fake! Not only did I receive an education, he provided me with the necessary information on what to look for when considering future purchases! He was genuinely interested in my best interests. Thank you very much Mr. Knight - I'll be back!!!