Business Details
Authentic New York Style Pizza & Wings in Southwest Florida
At Al Primo Pizzeria, we take pride in serving Southwest Florida with authentic New York-style pizza and buffalo-style chicken wings crafted to perfection. Our commitment to traditional preparation methods ensures every slice delivers the rich heritage of Italian-inspired cuisine paired with the bold flavors of western New York. With six strategically located restaurants, we prioritize convenience without compromising quality, using fresh ingredients to create time-honored recipes.Our streamlined menu focuses on excellence in core offerings, from classic cheese pizzas to customizable toppings and signature wing varieties. Recognizing our community's role in our success, we maintain a customer-centric approach through consistent service improvements and local engagement. Our team combines decades of culinary experience with a passion for hospitality, ensuring every visit reflects our dedication to flavor, efficiency, and genuine care for our patrons.
Services
Pizza
Wings
Catering
Online Ordering
Gift Cards
Highlights and features
- We specialize in traditional New York-style pizza made with time-tested recipes
- Our buffalo wings originate from western New York's authentic preparation methods
- Six strategically located restaurants ensure convenient access across Southwest Florida
- Streamlined menu guarantees consistent quality in core pizza and wing offerings
- Community-focused business model prioritizes customer feedback and local engagement
What people say
Perfect New York slice
Authentic buffalo wing flavor
Multiple convenient locations
Consistent quality across visits
Great catering options
Services
New York Style Pizza
Hand-tossed New York-style pizza featuring premium mozzarella cheese and house-made tomato sauce on a thin, crispy crust. Available in traditional cheese or customizable with over a dozen fresh toppings. Perfect for individual enjoyment or family sharing, our pizzas combine authentic preparation methods with modern flavor preferences.
Buffalo Style Wings
Authentic buffalo-style chicken wings originating from western New York traditions. Available in multiple heat levels with classic wing sauces, served with fresh-cut fries or as part of combination meals. Prepared to order with options for boneless or traditional wing formats.
Catering Services
Full-service catering for corporate events, family gatherings, and special occasions featuring our signature pizza and wing offerings. Customizable menus with bulk ordering options, delivery arrangements, and serving equipment available. Designed to accommodate groups of all sizes with advance ordering capabilities.
Online Ordering
Convenient online ordering platform for pickup or delivery of our complete menu offerings. Features real-time order tracking, digital payment integration, and exclusive online-only promotions. Available 24/7 through our website with estimated preparation time notifications.
Gift Cards
Flexible-value gift cards available for purchase in-store or online, redeemable across all menu items and locations. Ideal for special occasions, employee recognition programs, or spontaneous gifts. Features customizable denominations and digital gift card options.
Questions
What pizza styles do you offer?
We specialize in traditional New York-style pizza with thin, crispy crusts and premium toppings. Available in classic cheese or customizable with over a dozen topping options.
Are catering services available for large orders?
Yes, we offer full catering services with bulk pizza and wing options, delivery arrangements, and serving equipment for events of all sizes.
Do you have online ordering capabilities?
Yes, our 24/7 online ordering system allows for easy pickup or delivery arrangements with real-time tracking and digital payment integration.
What wing sauce options are available?
We offer traditional buffalo sauce in multiple heat levels, along with specialty sauces and dipping options for both bone-in and boneless wing varieties.
How many locations do you operate?
We currently serve Southwest Florida through six strategically located restaurants in Cape Coral, Golden Gate, Lehigh Acres, Naples Walk, North Port, and Port Charlotte.
Reviews (5)
John C.
Dec 31, 2021
Report
Great wings, great pizza and fast service, excellent choice for a quick meal that is much higher quality than your typical fast food
Cary Leimbach
Nov 21, 2021
Report
This location can handle a big crowd and turn our excellent pizza and wings! Friendly, hard-working staff, thank you!
Garrick Gaffigan
Oct 29, 2021
Report
Amazingly empty on a Saturday night, which was concerning. But the pizza was really good, with fresh, identifiable ingredients.
Lynne Thornton
Sep 16, 2021
Report
Food was really good but service was the worst. It was like they didnt want us there. We arrive to dine in about 35 min before closing i asked if we can still dine in and they said yes so we order. Another employee came up and told us like twice that they close at 9 and that we had to be out by then. For our fountain drinks we had to go up and ask for the cups. Our food arrives i asked if they had plates and the guy said yeah their up there. We had to get our own! Im at a restaurant i expect to be served, if i wanted to get everything myself i would have ate at home.
Camila Ramon Cami
Jul 15, 2021
Report
Kids eat for five every Wednesday, they made their personal pizza, a cookie and small drink. The wings are awesome! Juicy inside and crunchy outside, with the sauce of your choice. Now lets talk about pizza: the Il primo special pizza has all the flavors and a lot of cheese! Definitely a good place, good food, good price and good service.