Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Emergency
services
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Sebringville, ON
At Tradition Mutual, we simplify insurance for our clients, offering clear and comprehensive coverage for farms, automobiles, businesses, and properties. With a legacy spanning 145 years, we provide safety, security, and certainty to our policyholders in an unpredictable world. Our mutual insurance model ensures that our clients are also owners, prioritizing their needs above all else. Backed by Ontario Mutuals, one of the strongest financial networks globally, we deliver stability and security through personalized service rooted in local communities. We believe a local view means better insurance, investing in the communities we serve while offering coverage tailored to individual needs.

Our expertise extends to auto, residential, farm, and commercial insurance, designed to protect assets and income. We are committed to exceptional customer care, streamlined claims processes, and eco-friendly practices. Our partnerships with dedicated brokers ensure expert guidance, while our community initiatives reflect our dedication to social responsibility. With offices in St. Marys, Stratford, Mitchell, and Perth and Huron counties, we combine deep local knowledge with global financial strength. Our mission is to build long-term relationships through peace of mind, innovation, and a members-first approach.
Services
Auto Insurance Residential Insurance Farm Insurance Commercial Insurance Claims Support
Highlights and features
  • We offer 145 years of expertise in mutual insurance tailored to local needs.
  • Our policyholders are also owners, ensuring client-centric service.
  • We provide personalized coverage for auto, farm, residential, and commercial risks.
  • Our partnerships with local brokers ensure community-specific expertise.
  • We combine global financial strength with local investment and sustainability.
What people say
Personalized coverage Local community focus Responsive claims team 145-year legacy Eco-friendly practices
Services
Auto Insurance
We provide customized auto insurance for personal and recreational vehicles, including pickups, SUVs, motorcycles, and RVs. Our policies protect against accidents, theft, and damage while offering competitive rates. With local broker support, clients receive tailored plans that adapt to evolving needs.
Residential Insurance
Our residential insurance covers homeowners and renters with policies protecting property, belongings, and liability. Coverage includes structural damage, personal asset loss, and legal responsibilities. Local agents help build plans that reflect individual living situations and regional risks.
Farm Insurance
We offer comprehensive farm insurance for large-scale operations, hobby farms, and cash crop businesses. Policies protect buildings, machinery, livestock, crops, and income loss. Our expertise ensures coverage aligns with the unique risks of farming in Ontario's rural communities.
Commercial Insurance
Our commercial insurance safeguards business assets and income against unforeseen events like fires, theft, or liability claims. Tailored solutions cover physical property, equipment, and operational income loss. Local brokers ensure policies match industry-specific needs.
Claims Support
We streamline claims with 24/7 emergency service and online reporting. Clients receive dedicated advisor support during business hours, while after-hours claims are directed to urgent response teams. Our process prioritizes fast, transparent resolution of covered losses.
People
Charles MacLennan
CEO
Charles MacLennan leads Tradition Mutual with a focus on innovation and community investment. He previously served as incoming CEO before succeeding Paul Burns in 2024, continuing a legacy of local stewardship.
Paul Burns
Retiring CEO
Paul Burns served as CEO for multiple years, overseeing Tradition Mutual's growth and community initiatives. He retired in 2024 after passing leadership to Charles MacLennan, leaving a legacy of mutual ownership values.
Questions
What types of insurance does Tradition Mutual offer?
We provide auto, residential, farm, and commercial insurance tailored to Ontario communities, with coverage for vehicles, homes, agricultural operations, and business assets.
How do I file a claim?
Submit claims online via our website or call 1-877-380-6402 during business hours. After-hours emergencies use the same number for urgent assistance.
Are payment plans available?
Yes, we accept credit/debit cards, cash, cheques, and online bill payments. Preauthorized payments can be arranged through your broker.
Is Tradition Mutual locally owned?
Yes, we're 100% Canadian and locally invested, with brokers in St. Marys, Stratford, Mitchell, and Huron County communities.
How does the mutual ownership model benefit me?
As a policyholder, you're an owner with voting rights. Profits are reinvested to improve coverage and community initiatives.
Reviews (2)
Lukasz Kabata
Aug 11, 2021 Report
My mom and I have vehicle insurance and home insurance and all the insurance representatives are wonderful, knowledgeable and have the best rates possible. We advised all our family and friends to make the switch to Traditional Mutual Insurance!
Daniel Patton
Dec 09, 2019 Report
Great team to work with and honest. Was very impressed with Kyle and his knowledge of product and options. He took the time to explain in detail the different choices we had and we were very impressed. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for insurance!