Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
Authentic Italian Pizza with a New York Twist
At Pizza Di Nonna, we are dedicated to crafting authentic Italian, New York-inspired pizzas that honor traditional techniques while embracing modern innovation. Our dough undergoes a 72-hour cold fermentation process, ensuring a rich flavor and perfect texture, and is hand-tugged daily using Caputo Italian flour milled in Naples. We source premium ingredients like Bianco DiNapoli organic tomatoes, Ezzo Sausage Co. pepperoni, and Venetian Meats artisanal charcuterie to deliver unparalleled quality in every bite. Our commitment to authenticity extends to our hand-stretched crusts, fresh basil, and fragrant oregano, all prepared without chemicals or shortcuts.

With a focus on community and customer satisfaction, we strive to create memorable dining experiences through our diverse menu of specialty pies and customizable toppings. Our team, led by passionate pizza artisans, takes pride in serving Grimsby with warm hospitality and a dedication to excellence that shines through in every slice. From our kitchen to your table, we ensure that every pizza reflects our values of quality, tradition, and genuine passion for the craft.
Services
Margherita Pizza Farmer's Garden Pizza Honey Inferno Pizza Brisket Pizza Chicken Sandwich Garlic Bread Wings Custom Toppings Takeout Dine-in
Highlights and features
  • We use 72-hour cold-fermented dough for deep flavor and perfect texture.
  • Our hand-tugged crusts are made with Caputo Italian flour from Naples.
  • We source Bianco DiNapoli organic tomatoes, the #1 organic tomatoes on the market.
  • Premium meats like Ezzo Sausage Co. pepperoni ensure exceptional quality.
  • Our team prioritizes authenticity, tradition, and customer satisfaction.
What people say
Delicious pizza every time Friendly and accommodating staff Fresh ingredients and bold flavors Creative menu items Personalized service
Services
Margherita Pizza
Our Margherita Pizza celebrates simplicity with Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes, fresh basil, oregano, and aged Parmigiano Reggiano. The 72-hour fermented dough creates a light, airy crust, delivering a perfect balance of traditional Italian flavors in every bite.
Honey Inferno Pizza
The Honey Inferno combines premium cup-and-char pepperoni, fresh jalapeos, and Mike's Hot Honey for a fiery yet sweet flavor profile. This pizza offers a bold twist on classic toppings, ensuring a memorable and indulgent experience.
Brisket Pizza
Topped with slow-cooked brisket and drizzled with hot honey, this pizza blends savory and sweet notes. The hand-tugged crust supports generous portions of premium meat, creating a hearty, satisfying option for meat lovers.
Custom Toppings
Create your ideal pizza with our wide selection of gourmet toppings, from fresh vegetables to artisanal meats. Each custom creation uses our signature 72-hour dough and house-made sauce for consistent quality and flavor.
Garlic Bread
Our garlic bread features crispy, golden slices infused with aromatic garlic and herbs. Made with the same high-quality dough as our pizzas, it serves as a perfect complement to any meal, offering a savory start to your dining experience.
Questions
What makes Pizza Di Nonna's pizza authentic?
We use traditional Italian techniques like 72-hour cold fermentation dough, Caputo flour, and Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes to ensure authentic flavor and texture.
Do you offer vegetarian pizza options?
Yes! Try our Farmer's Garden Pizza with mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, and black olives for a wholesome vegetarian choice.
Are there gluten-free options available?
While we don't offer gluten-free crusts, our menu includes naturally gluten-reduced options like our garlic bread and select salads.
How can I place an order?
Order online through our website or visit us in person at 297 Lake St, Grimsby, during our operating hours for takeout or dine-in.
Do you cater events or large orders?
Yes, we accommodate large orders for events. Contact us directly to discuss custom menus and arrangements for your gathering.
Reviews (4)
Kayren Horvath
Jan 08, 2022 Report
Oh wow! Ordered mushroom, pepperoni, red onions! Sooooo good! Loaded. Mushrooms! ! Great price! Super friendly staff! Great service! Support local!!!
Liane Fougere
Oct 22, 2021 Report
There's 6 pizza places in Grimsby not including this place bc this place blows everything out of the water. give it a try and you won't be disappointed!
Ken Bell
Oct 03, 2021 Report
New to the area and tried this for the first time. Was very happy with the pizza quality, taste and price.
Andrew Dubs
Sep 12, 2021 Report
Grimsby.. I i have taken time too write this but.. If you a true heart of Grimsby this place is no heavy duty pizza. Its okay but it has not convicted me. So take it as it is. Its my review on the pizza i liked it but i did not enjoyed it.