Call Now
Website
Call
Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Independent Insurance Broker in Belleville
Mackay Insurance was founded in 1974 with a commitment to providing independent insurance services rooted in honesty and integrity. Over nearly five decades, we have grown to serve over 12,000 clients across Eastern Ontario while maintaining our core values of client-focused service and community involvement. Our independence allows us to partner with nearly 20 insurance providers, ensuring tailored coverage that prioritizes your needs.

With a team of nearly 30 dedicated professionals, we combine deep local expertise with a personalized approach to protect what matters most to you. Our legacy, built by founder Dave Mackay and continued by President Bruce Mackay, reflects a steadfast dedication to integrity, service, and community stewardship.
Services
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Life Insurance Business Insurance Specialty Insurance
Details
  • Year established: 1974
Highlights and features
  • We offer unbiased advice from nearly 20 insurance providers.
  • Our independence ensures your best interests are our priority.
  • With over 45 years of local expertise, we provide tailored coverage.
  • We provide more coverage options than any other broker in the region.
  • We are committed to serving the Eastern Ontario community with integrity.
What people say
Unbiased advice Knowledgeable representation Timely service Great to work with Enjoyable experience
Services
Home Insurance
Protect your home with customized policies covering structural damage, personal belongings, and liability. Our brokers compare 20+ providers to find optimal coverage for condos, cottages, and primary residences across Eastern Ontario.
Auto Insurance
Secure comprehensive or liability-only coverage for cars, trucks, and specialty vehicles. We offer competitive rates and tailored policies for drivers of all ages and experience levels in Belleville and surrounding areas.
Business Insurance
Safeguard your enterprise with liability, property, and risk management solutions. Our brokers specialize in policies for small to mid-sized businesses across diverse industries in Eastern Ontario.
Life Insurance
Plan for your family's future with term or permanent life insurance. We provide policies that ensure financial stability for dependents, funeral expenses, or estate planning needs.
Specialty Insurance
Address niche needs through specialty policies for travel trailers, recreational vehicles, and unique properties. Our brokers secure coverage where standard policies fall short.
People
Bruce Mackay
President
President since 2003, Bruce Mackay has over 30 years of insurance experience. He oversees daily operations and maintains his father's legacy of integrity while expanding services to meet modern needs.
Holly Phillips
Branch Manager-Belleville
With Mackay since 1990, Holly Phillips manages the Belleville branch. Her 30+ years of expertise and CAIB designation ensure clients receive knowledgeable guidance for all insurance needs.
Kelly Wieler
Branch Manager-Napanee
Bringing 40+ years of insurance experience, Kelly Wieler leads the Napanee office. His expertise in sales and branch management ensures personalized service for local residential and commercial clients.
Davin Hanninen
Sales Manager-Belleville
As Sales Manager, Davin Hanninen combines insurance expertise with community involvement. He specializes in new business development while coaching local hockey teams and supporting family activities.
Paul Griffin
Sales - In-House New Business
Paul Griffin transitioned from pastoral work to insurance in 2012. His CAIB designation and 20+ years of customer service experience help clients navigate complex insurance decisions with clarity.
Questions
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide home, auto, life, business, and specialty insurance policies tailored to individual and commercial needs across Eastern Ontario.
How are you different from other brokers?
As Belleville's only independent broker since 1977, we partner with 20+ providers to offer unbiased advice and customized coverage options.
How do I file a claim?
Contact our Belleville or Napanee office directly during business hours. Our team will guide you through the process and advocate for your best interests.
Do you serve areas outside Belleville?
Yes, we serve all of Eastern Ontario, including Napanee, Quinte West, and surrounding communities with personalized insurance solutions.
Can I get insurance for unique properties?
Yes, our specialty insurance division handles coverage for travel trailers, cottages, and other unique properties where standard policies may not apply.
Videos
Reviews (6)
Abbigail Mackay
Oct 20, 2021 Report
Im biased but I always love calling Liz in reception even if I dont have any business to do! If they could represent across the provinces Id have my car insured with them from BC! Maybe a new location??
Christine Faria
Dec 08, 2020 Report
Mackay Insurance is an Honest, kind company that has been wonderful and engaging in the community and has provided unbiased support and answered questions and shares detailed information. They are transparent and awesome!
Jane Hunt
Dec 08, 2020 Report
Great customer service, prompt responses with excellent follow up. Plus they provide an extensive product line, offering competitive rates.
Melissa Bernice
Dec 07, 2020 Report
Great company that supports the community. They have always been great to help us out with any insurance questions we may have.
Jan Pixley
Dec 07, 2020 Report
The staff are friendly, knowledgeable and eager to help you get the best price for your insurance. They are great to deal with and give a lot back to the community.
Andrea Lisk
Dec 07, 2020 Report
We've been with them for years. Appreciate their help, their willingness to look into things for us and for their huge generous hearts. Highly recommend.